Prepaid 2 Dozen Cookies (Free Shipping)

Sale price$140.85
4.4 (12 reviews)

Tax excluded.

What makes a better gift than cookies? Sending them as a subscription to a loved one or friend each and every month!

With our prepaid cookies 2 dozen subscription, 24 new cookie of the month flavors (4 of each flavor) will be sent to your recipients doorstep each and every month. Not only is it the gift that just keeps on giving, but you know it will never go to waste. Of course, you can always gift them to yourself as well. We're not judging!

Length of Subscription: 3 Months
Currently Baking

November 2023


Chocolate Pop Tart Cookies
Chocolate Pop Tart Cookies Made with a milk chocolate dough, chocolate pop tart crumbs, chocolate chips and a generous vanilla drizzle.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Cinnamon Roll Cookies
Cinnamon Roll Cookies Our Cinnamon Roll cookies are made with cinnamon dough, our signature white chocolate cinnamon truffle and a savory cream cheese glaze. They'll have you feeling all warm and happy inside!
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Mint Hot Cocoa Cookies
Mint Hot Cocoa Cookies Made with a milk chocolate dough and andes mint, these mint hot chocolate cookies will be your new favorites very quickly.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Orange Cranberry Cookies
Orange Cranberry Cookies White chocolate chips, tartness from our orange-infused dough, dried cranberries, and an orange reduction. Now that's quintessential autumn flavor.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Pumpkin Dark Chocolate Cookies
Pumpkin Dark Chocolate Cookies Pumpkin pie infused-dough packed into a cookie with dark chocolate chunks and a decadent dark chocolate drizzle. We might just call it the perfect fall dessert.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
1 Spiced caramel oatmeal cookie
Spiced Caramel Oatmeal Cookies Enjoy one of our Spiced Caramel Oatmeal cookies with your favorite hot beverage or as a special treat all on its own.
Sale priceFrom $18.95

Customer Reviews

Based on 12 reviews
Brian Filler
Filler Cookie Monster

Outstanding! Enjoyed every morsel!

Tracy Fauver

Prepaid 2 Dozen Cookies

Andrew Faustini
Great cookies...bad communication

I subscribed for 3 months and received my first month and the cookies are scrumptious. I ordered them during a buy and get 6 free cookies and never received those. I emailed about a week ago and still haven't heard back about why or why I did not receive them.

Tina Timmers

Great Variety! I was envisioning more of a "roll-out" sugar cookie type and wasn't sure what the consistency would be like?...Crunchy, crispy, soft, dense... Each cookie/flavor that I received had a soft airy consistency. Very good. Excited to try next months!!!

Scott Fattic
Cookie Subscsription

We purchased the 3 month subscription service as a gift and it was thoroughly enjoyed. The cookies arrived on time and fresh every month and we were told that it was impossible to pick a favorite because they were all so good