Most Popular Products

Filters

Sort by:

81 products

Prepaid
Subscription
Prepaid Half Dozen CookiesPrepaid Half Dozen Cookies
With our prepaid half a dozen cookies subscription, 6 new cookie of the month flavors will be sent to your recipients doorstep each and every month. Half dozen prepaid subscriptions are excluded from free shipping. $6.95 per month will be charged with your prepaid order at checkout.
Sale priceFrom $44.85
Mix
Best Seller's MixBest Seller's Mix
With just the right amount of playfulness, color, and imagination, we guarantee you'll be coming back for more.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Build Your Own Box
Sale priceFrom $36.95
Prepaid
Subscription
Prepaid 1 Dozen CookiesPrepaid 1 Dozen Cookies
With our prepaid cookies 1 dozen subscription, 12 new cookie of the month flavors (2 of each flavor) will be sent to your recipients doorstep each and every month.
Sale priceFrom $80.85
Subscription
The Crave Club MembershipThe Crave Club Membership
Cookies delivered to your door monthly? Sitewide free shipping? Exclusive discounts and giveaways! Yes please!
Sale priceFrom $16.95
Best Seller
ube cookie flatlayube cookies stacked
It's sweet. It's savory. It's everything you want in a cookie. Our Ube was so popular it's been added to our signature flavor menu!
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Signature Flavor
Best Seller
Lemon Bar CookiesLemon Bar Cookies stacked
Fresh lemon zest, lemon juice, vanilla chips, lemon pudding & powdered sugar...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Signature Flavor
Best Seller
Ultimate chocolate chip cookie flatlayUltimate Chocolate Chip Cookies stacked
Semisweet Milk & Dark Chocolate Chips with a generous sprinkle of sea salt...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Mix
Half and half mix
Our Half and Half Cookies Mix gives you 6 of our Best Sellers and our 6 new Cookie of the Month flavors.
Sale price$29.95
Mix
adventurous mix cookies in boxadventurous cookies stacked
Cookie connoisseurs take note, this Adventurous Cookies Mix box was made for you. For those who crave something wild, a spicy cookie, a meaty cookie, this box has it all.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Signature Flavor
Best Seller
Birthday Cake CookiesBirthday Cake Cookies
Funfetti cake batter, vanilla chips, and rainbow sprinkles both inside and out...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Signature Flavor
Best Seller
Cookie Monster CookiesCookie Monster Cookies
Caramel bites, Oreos, mini marshmallows, white chocolate chips, and semisweet chocolate chips...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Mix
chocoholics mix cookies in boxChocoholics Mix, Gourmet Cookies - red velvet, ultimate chocolate chip, chocolate truffle closeup
With our most popular chocolate cookies, you can easily step into gooey, velvety, rich paradise. Just don't blame us if you get lost there.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Signature Flavor
Best Seller
Salted Caramel Cream cookieSalted Caramel Cream cookies stacked
Salted caramel, vanilla chips and a generous sprinkle of sea salt...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Signature Flavor
PB Overload CookiePB Overload Cookies stacked
Made with an extra nutty dough that is mixed with Resseโ€™s and Guittard chocolate chips, this cookie is next level decadent and smooth.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Signature Flavor
Best Seller
Red Velvet CookieRed Velvet Cookies stacked
Red velvet cake batter, cream cheese truffles, and vanilla chips...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Save 25%
Mix
Ultimate cookie box - 48 cookies
Be delighted, be surprised, be happy you have 48 cookies to eat and share, because this cookie box is the ultimate cookie lovers dream come true.
Sale price$89.95 Regular price$119.80
Prepaid
Subscription
Prepaid 2 Dozen Cookies (Free Shipping)Prepaid 2 Dozen Cookies (Free Shipping)
With our prepaid cookies 2 dozen subscription, 24 new cookie of the month flavors (4 of each flavor) will be sent to your recipients doorstep each and every month.
Sale priceFrom $140.85
Signature Flavor
Almond Joyous cookieAlmond Joyous cookies stacked
This could really be one of the best cookies to EVER come out of The Cravory Kitchen. We're serious. A toasted coconut dough, mixed with sweetened coconut, toasted almonds, Guittard Dark Chocolate Chunks then rolled in coconut and topped with Maldon sea salt and a semisweet chocolate drizzle.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Signature Flavor
Chocolate Truffle CookieChocolate Truffle Cookies stacked
Rich chocolate dough meets Guittard Chocolate Chunks and Truffles with a White chocolate drizzle. Pure lusciousness. VIP only. Lifestyles of the rich and famous.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Signature Flavor
taro cookietaro cookies stacked
Itโ€™s hard to place a finger on what taro tastes like โ€“ a bit of vanilla, a tad floral, and a little nutty, borderline tropical maybe? Either way, we can guarantee your taste buds will love it.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Gluten Free Ultimate Chocolate Chip cookieGluten Free Ultimate Chocolate Chip cookies stacked
Calling all those who are gluten sensitive! We've got something made special just for you. Our Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie is so good, we just had to make a gluten-free version!
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Signature Flavor
Pancakes And Bacon CookiePancakes And Bacon Cookies stacked
Filled with hand-chopped maple smoked bacon in a pancake dough, this cookie combines the best of both worlds while taking you on a savory tastebud adventure.
Sale priceFrom $19.95