Old Cookie Flavors

Filters

Sort by:

173 products

February
Old Flavor
Mix
February Mix CookiesFebruary Mix Cookies
Our February Cookie Mix, featuring the sweet Strawberry Kiss Cookie and cinnamon-caramel Biscoff Drop Cookie, is the perfect Valentine’s Day gift to share or enjoy yourself!
Sale priceFrom $19.95
February
Old Flavor
Biscoff drops cookie singleBiscoff Drops cookies stack of six cookies
This cookie combines Biscoff dough, creamy Biscoff spread, crunchy Biscoff cookie pieces, dark chocolate chunks, and semi-sweet chocolate chips for a decadent treat bursting with spiced, nutty, and chocolatey flavors.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
November
Old Flavor
Harvest Spice CrunchHarvest Spice Crunch
Enjoy the essence of autumn with our Harvest Spice Crunch Cookie, featuring pumpkin dough, real pumpkin, crunchy walnuts, and semisweet chocolate chips for a delightful seasonal treat.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
November
Old Flavor
Spicy Hot Cocoa CookiesSpicy Hot Cocoa Cookies
Savor the unique flavor of our Spicy Hot Cocoa Cookie, featuring dark chocolate dough infused with cinnamon, chili, and cayenne pepper, and packed with dark chocolate chunks, semisweet chocolate chips, and mini marshmallows for a delightful kick.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
November
Old Flavor
Maple Almond CookiesMaple Almond Cookies
Delight in the rich flavors of our Maple Almond Cookie, featuring oatmeal dough, a creamy maple white chocolate truffle, and roasted almonds for a sweet and satisfying treat.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
November
Old Flavor
Apple Crisp CookiesApple Crisp Cookies
Savor the taste of fall with our Apple Crisp Cookie, featuring apple dough, dried apples, cider reduction, and crunchy ginger snap cookie bits for a perfect blend of sweet and spice.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
November
Old Flavor
Cinnamon Roll CookiesCinnamon Roll Cookies
Enjoy the comforting flavors of our Cinnamon Roll Cookie, filled with white chocolate cinnamon cream cheese truffle, white chocolate chips, and topped with cinnamon sugar for a sweet and spiced treat.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
November
Old Flavor
Cranberry Orange Burst CookiesCranberry Orange Burst Cookies
Enjoy a refreshing blend of sweet and tangy with our Cranberry Orange Burst Cookie, featuring zesty orange dough, white chocolate chips, dried cranberries, and an orange reduction
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Cookie of the Month Mix
Old Flavor
Halloween Box - Cookie of the Month MixHalloween Box - Cookie of the Month Mix
Get ready to celebrate the spookiest time of the year with our Halloween-themed Cookie of the Month Mix cookie box.
Sale priceFrom $34.95
Best Seller's Mix
Old Flavor
Halloween Box - Best Seller's MixHalloween Box - Best Seller's Mix
Get ready to celebrate the spookiest time of the year with our Halloween-themed Best Seller's Mix cookie box.
Sale priceFrom $34.95
October
Old Flavor
Black Cat CookiesBlack Cat Cookies
Featuring blackberry dough, dark chocolate chunks, semisweet chocolate chips, and a swirl of tangy blackberry jam...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
October
Old Flavor
Nutty Zombie single cookikeNutty Zombie stacked cookie
A crunchy and zesty treat with pistachio dough, roasted pistachios, lemon zest, and white chocolate chips...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
October
Old Flavor
Jack O' Lantern CookiesJack O' Lantern Cookies
Vanilla dough, crunchy Butterfinger pieces, and festive orange and black sprinkles...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
October
Old Flavor
Hocus pocus single cookieHocus pocus stacked cookies
Rich milk chocolate dough, brownie bites, chocolate chunks, roasted walnuts, and a sprinkle of Maldon sea salt...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
October
Old Flavor
Vampire Treats CookiesVampire Treats Cookies
A spooky treat made with vanilla dough, colorful M+M’s, crunchy Kit Kat pieces, and gooey mini marshmallows...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
October
Old Flavor
Pumpkin Potion CookiesPumpkin Potion Cookies
Embrace the flavors of fall with our Pumpkin Potion Cookie, made with pumpkin dough, roasted pumpkin, oats, maple syrup, dried cranberries, and warm spices...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
September
Old Flavor
Strawberry cream pie single cookieStrawberry cream pie stack of six cookies
Savor the nostalgic flavors of our Strawberry Cream Pie Cookie, with buttery shortbread dough, strawberry jam, a strawberry white chocolate truffle, and a vanilla drizzle for a delightfully indulgent treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
September
Old Flavor
Spiced apple chai single cookieSpiced apple chai stack of six cookies
Enjoy the warm, comforting flavors of our Spiced Apple Chai Cookie, featuring chai-infused dough, tender spiced apples, and crunchy Nilla wafers for a delightful treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
September
Old Flavor
Nutella wonder single cookieNutella wonder stack of six cookies
Delight in our Nutella Wonder Cookie, featuring Nutella-infused dough, roasted hazelnuts, swirls of Nutella, and semisweet chocolate chips for a rich and indulgent treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
September
Old Flavor
Chewy butterscotch single cookieChewy butterscotch stack of six cookies
Savor the rich, buttery sweetness of our Chewy Butterscotch Cookie, featuring butterscotch dough, dark chocolate callets, butterscotch chips, and a sprinkle of Maldon sea salt for a perfectly balanced treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
September
Old Flavor
Cherry granola single cookieCherry granola six cookies stacked
Savor the wholesome goodness of our Cherry Granola Cookie, featuring granola dough, cherry jam, dried cherries, oats, and granola for a perfect blend of sweet and chewy flavors.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
September
Old Flavor
Brookie single cookieBrookie stack of six cookies
Relish our Brookie Cookie, a decadent blend of brownie batter dough, semisweet chocolate chips, milk chocolate chunks, chewy brownie bites, and a dark chocolate drizzle for an ultimate chocolate indulgence.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
August
Old Flavor
Matcha Bliss CookiesMatcha Bliss Cookies
Indulge in the refreshing essence of summer with our Matcha Bliss cookie, a delightful treat that perfectly balances the invigorating notes of matcha with the luxurious creaminess of white chocolate, offering a cool and satisfying escape from the warm sun.
Sale priceFrom $19.95