Old Cookie Flavors

Filters

Sort by:

192 products

OctoberSold out
Old Flavor
Hocus pocus single cookieHocus pocus stacked cookies
Rich milk chocolate dough, brownie bites, chocolate chunks, roasted walnuts, and a sprinkle of Maldon sea salt...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
OctoberSold out
Old Flavor
Vampire Treats CookiesVampire Treats Cookies
A spooky treat made with vanilla dough, colorful M+M’s, crunchy Kit Kat pieces, and gooey mini marshmallows...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
OctoberSold out
Old Flavor
Pumpkin Potion CookiesPumpkin Potion Cookies
Embrace the flavors of fall with our Pumpkin Potion Cookie, made with pumpkin dough, roasted pumpkin, oats, maple syrup, dried cranberries, and warm spices...
Sale priceFrom $19.95
SeptemberSold out
Old Flavor
Mix
September mix cookies stackedSeptember mix cookies in box
Embrace back-to-school season with our September Cookie Mix, featuring a variety of flavors including Spiced Apple Chai, Strawberry Cream Pie, Cherry Granola, Nutella Wonder, Chewy Butterscotch, and Brookie Cookie for a delightful and diverse treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
SeptemberSold out
Old Flavor
Strawberry cream pie single cookieStrawberry cream pie stack of six cookies
Savor the nostalgic flavors of our Strawberry Cream Pie Cookie, with buttery shortbread dough, strawberry jam, a strawberry white chocolate truffle, and a vanilla drizzle for a delightfully indulgent treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
SeptemberSold out
Old Flavor
Spiced apple chai single cookieSpiced apple chai stack of six cookies
Enjoy the warm, comforting flavors of our Spiced Apple Chai Cookie, featuring chai-infused dough, tender spiced apples, and crunchy Nilla wafers for a delightful treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
SeptemberSold out
Old Flavor
Nutella wonder single cookieNutella wonder stack of six cookies
Delight in our Nutella Wonder Cookie, featuring Nutella-infused dough, roasted hazelnuts, swirls of Nutella, and semisweet chocolate chips for a rich and indulgent treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
SeptemberSold out
Old Flavor
Chewy butterscotch single cookieChewy butterscotch stack of six cookies
Savor the rich, buttery sweetness of our Chewy Butterscotch Cookie, featuring butterscotch dough, dark chocolate callets, butterscotch chips, and a sprinkle of Maldon sea salt for a perfectly balanced treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
SeptemberSold out
Old Flavor
Cherry granola single cookieCherry granola six cookies stacked
Savor the wholesome goodness of our Cherry Granola Cookie, featuring granola dough, cherry jam, dried cherries, oats, and granola for a perfect blend of sweet and chewy flavors.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
SeptemberSold out
Old Flavor
Brookie single cookieBrookie stack of six cookies
Relish our Brookie Cookie, a decadent blend of brownie batter dough, semisweet chocolate chips, milk chocolate chunks, chewy brownie bites, and a dark chocolate drizzle for an ultimate chocolate indulgence.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
AugustSold out
Old Flavor
Mix
August Mix CookiesAugust Mix Cookies
Savor the delights of August with our tantalizing array of cookies that celebrate the best of summer in every bite.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
AugustSold out
Old Flavor
Matcha Bliss CookiesMatcha Bliss Cookies
Indulge in the refreshing essence of summer with our Matcha Bliss cookie, a delightful treat that perfectly balances the invigorating notes of matcha with the luxurious creaminess of white chocolate, offering a cool and satisfying escape from the warm sun.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
AugustSold out
Old Flavor
Peachy Keen CookiesPeachy Keen Cookies
Indulge in the sweetest days of summer with our irresistible Peachy Keen cookie, a delectable treat that captures the essence of a sun-kissed orchard, bursting with dried peaches, velvety peach jam, creamy Nilla Wafers, and a sprinkle of white chocolate chips.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
AugustSold out
Old Flavor
Fig Delight CookiesFig Delight Cookies
Savor the enchanting flavors of our Fig Delight cookie, a heavenly treat that marries the luscious sweetness of figs with aromatic cinnamon, golden honey, and toasted walnuts. Crowned with a lavish sprinkle of dried figs for an indulgence that will captivate your senses.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
AugustSold out
Old Flavor
PB & B CookiesPB & B Cookies
Indulge in our irresistible PB & B cookie, a perfect blend of sweet bananas, crunchy banana chips, creamy peanut butter chips, and decadent peanut butter cups that will quickly become one of your favorites.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
AugustSold out
Old Flavor
Triple Chocolate CrunchTriple Chocolate Crunch
Embark on the ultimate chocolate adventure with our Triple Chocolate Crunch cookie: an indulgent dark chocolate dough loaded with generous chunks of smooth white chocolate and rich semisweet chocolate chips.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
AugustSold out
Old Flavor
Coconut Zing CookiesCoconut Zing Cookies
Our Coconut Zing cookie is a heavenly coconut treat filled with lemon jam, lucious white chocolate, and velvety lemon truffle, lavishly topped with toasted coconut shavings for an irresistible crunch.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
JulySold out
Old Flavor
July Mix CookiesJuly Mix Cookies
Celebrate Independence Day and the flavors of summer with our July Cookie Mix, featuring a delightful assortment including Coconut Tiki Bar, Orange Creamsicle, Beach Bonfire S'mores, Berry Basil Breeze, Tropical Trail Mix, and Sunset Love cookies for a festive and delicious holiday treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
JulySold out
Old Flavor
Sunset Love CookiesSunset Love Cookies
Enjoy the tropical romance of our Sunset Love Cookie, featuring buttery shortbread dough filled with luscious passion fruit jam and guava marmalade for a sweet and tangy delight in every bite.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
JulySold out
Old Flavor
Tropical Trail Mix CookiesTropical Trail Mix Cookies
Embark on a flavor adventure with our Tropical Trail Mix Cookie, packed with granola dough, oats, dried fruits, roasted almonds, and cashews for a perfect blend of sweet and nutty delight.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
JulySold out
Old Flavor
Berry Basil Breeze CookiesBerry Basil Breeze Cookies
Experience the unique blend of sweet and herbaceous flavors with our Berry Basil Cookie, featuring basil-infused dough, white chocolate strawberry truffle, white chocolate chips, basil puree, and a sprinkle of basil sugar.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
JulySold out
Old Flavor
Beach Bonfire S'mores CookiesBeach Bonfire S'mores Cookies
Relive summer nights with our Beach Bonfire S'mores Cookie, featuring graham cracker dough, mini marshmallows, and rich milk chocolate for the perfect nostalgic treat.
Sale priceFrom $15.95 Regular price$19.95
JulySold out
Old Flavor
Orange Creamsicle CookiesOrange Creamsicle Cookies
Enjoy a nostalgic treat with our Orange Creamsicle Cookie, featuring zesty orange dough, orange reduction, fresh orange zest, and creamy white chocolate chips for a delightful fusion of sweet and tangy flavors.
Sale priceFrom $19.95