Your Cart
0
Order
SHIPPING_PRICE more
to get
Free Shipping
!
Scroll down to see the rest of your cart!
Skip to content
Close menu
Subscriptions
All Subscriptions
3 Months Prepaid
6 Months Prepaid
12 Months Prepaid
Ongoing Subscriptions
Flavors
Mixes
Collections
Zakarian Collection
Bake At Home
Kids Collection
Cravory Coffee
Gift Cards
Our Story
Our Cookie Shops
Our Stockists
Corporate Gifting
Weddings & Events
Log in
Instagram
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Your Cart
Close cart
FREE Shipping
Orders of $35+ (not valid on subscriptions)
Corporate Gifting and Events
No order is too small or too large for us to handle.
Our Story
Our Cookie Shops
Our Stockists
Corporate Gifting
Weddings & Events
Instagram
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Our Story
Our Cookie Shops
Our Stockists
Corporate Gifting
Weddings & Events
Instagram
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Subscriptions
All Subscriptions
3 Months Prepaid
6 Months Prepaid
12 Months Prepaid
Ongoing Subscriptions
Flavors
Mixes
Collections
Zakarian Collection
Bake At Home
Kids Collection
Cravory Coffee
Gift Cards
Log in
Search
Site navigation
Cart
Search
"Close (esc)"
Home
/
Old Cookie Flavors
Filter
Sort
Sort
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sold Out
Pumpkin Dark Chocolate
2 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Pumpkin Custard
1 review
from $18.95
Sold Out
Chocolate Funnel Cake
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Passion Guava
2 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Pumpkin Pecan Pie
3 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Jack O'Lantern
3 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Mango Con Chili
3 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Oatmeal M&Ms
1 review
from $18.95
Sold Out
Krispy M&Ms
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Oatmeal Blueberry
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Pumpkin Graveyard
2 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Candy Corn Bark
3 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
White Chocolate Macadamia
1 review
from $18.95
Sold Out
Vanilla Sugar
1 review
from $18.95
Sold Out
Donut Glaze
2 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Wicked
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Ultimate S'mores
No reviews
from $18.95
Quick view
Toffee Love
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Tangerine Mimosa
2 reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Strawberry Pop Tart
1 review
from $18.95
Sold Out
Bloody Trick or Treat
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Almond Shortbread
1 review
from $18.95
Sold Out
Independence Day Mix
1 review
from $18.95
Sold Out
Cotton Candy
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Pina Colada
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Caramel Blondie Brownie
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Strawberry Sundae
No reviews
from $18.95
Sold Out
Funfetti Cheesecake
No reviews
from $18.95
Previous
1
2
3
Next
Toffee Love Cookies
No reviews
Regular price
$18.95
/
Simple is the ultimate sophistication.
Click
here to learn more
.
Customer Reviews
Be the first to write a review
Write a review
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
Previous
Next
"Close (esc)"