Best Seller's Mix

$18.95
/
Only -16552 items in stock!

Get a dose of our best sellers! Free shipping with the 18 Cookie Box and 2 Dozen box (as long as total purchase price after discounts is over $35).

These are the cookies that get you hooked and keep you asking for more. Even non-cookie lovers can't stop themselves with this Best Sellers Cookies Mix.

Includes our Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip, Cookie Monster, Lemon Bar, Salted Caramel Cream, and Red Velvet Cookies.

Contains: wheat, eggs, milk, and soy

Sending cookies as a gift?

We always consolidate the cookies into the fewest number of gifts boxes, but if you need them separated into separate gift boxes to hand out as gifts AND you are shipping to one location, please email us at info@thecravory.com. Due to shipping restraints, there may be an additional charge.

Shipping

+

I want to send the cookies to myself as a gift!

We always consolidate the cookies into the fewest number of gifts boxes, but if you need them separated into separate gift boxes to hand out as gifts AND you are shipping to one location, please reach out here before ordering.

If you are looking to ship to multiple locations, please order all individually. 

I want to add a gift message.

Please enter the gift message in the cart before checking out.

When can I expect my order to arrive?

We bake our cookies fresh to order, so they will be baked and shipped out fresh. Allow 1-2 business days for order processing until your cookies are shipped. Standard ground shipping is 3-4 business days. For expedited shipping, please call our office for options. 800.591.2571 or email us at info@thecravory.com

How are my cookies shipped and when can I expect them?

In order to deliver you the freshest cookies possible, we ship your order using FedEx Shipping methods for all orders within the continental U.S. The options for shipping methods include: FedEx Ground, or 2 Days Shipping. If shipping FedEx Ground, please allow up to 4 business days for the cookies to be delivered. For international shipping outside the US, extra shipping rates may apply. Please call in to order. To choose from these different expedited shipping options, please call our office at 800.591.2571. Please note that we bake Monday through Friday, and order’s placed after 1:00PM on Friday will be baked Monday.

Will shipping coupons and discounts apply to prepaid order?

We ship your order using FedEx Shipping methods for all orders within the continental U.S. Shipping coupons and discounts will only apply to one time orders, this includes our Free Shipping with orders over $50. Prepaid orders have multiple shipments which cannot include discounts for all the shipments.

What if I'm not satisfied with my product?

Our primary goal is to deliver you the ultimate cookie experience, and we 100% guarantee your satisfaction. If you are unhappy with any part of your Cravory order, PLEASE e-mail us directly at info@thecravory.com. If we are unable to solve the problem to your satisfaction we will provide you with a full refund of your cookie purchase.

  • Shipping

    • I want to send the cookies to myself as a gift!

    We always consolidate the cookies into the fewest number of gifts boxes, but if you need them separated into separate gift boxes to hand out as gifts AND you are shipping to one location, please reach out here before ordering.

    If you are looking to ship to multiple locations, please order all individually. 

    I want to add a gift message.

    Please enter the gift message in the cart before checking out.

    When can I expect my order to arrive?

    We bake our cookies fresh to order, so they will be baked and shipped out fresh. Allow 1-2 business days for order processing until your cookies are shipped. Standard ground shipping is 3-4 business days. For expedited shipping, please call our office for options. 800.591.2571 or email us at info@thecravory.com

    How are my cookies shipped and when can I expect them?

    In order to deliver you the freshest cookies possible, we ship your order using FedEx Shipping methods for all orders within the continental U.S. The options for shipping methods include: FedEx Ground, or 2 Days Shipping. If shipping FedEx Ground, please allow up to 4 business days for the cookies to be delivered. For international shipping outside the US, extra shipping rates may apply. Please call in to order. To choose from these different expedited shipping options, please call our office at 800.591.2571. Please note that we bake Monday through Friday, and order’s placed after 1:00PM on Friday will be baked Monday.

    Will shipping coupons and discounts apply to prepaid order?

    We ship your order using FedEx Shipping methods for all orders within the continental U.S. Shipping coupons and discounts will only apply to one time orders, this includes our Free Shipping with orders over $50. Prepaid orders have multiple shipments which cannot include discounts for all the shipments.

    What if I'm not satisfied with my product?

    Our primary goal is to deliver you the ultimate cookie experience, and we 100% guarantee your satisfaction. If you are unhappy with any part of your Cravory order, PLEASE e-mail us directly at info@thecravory.com. If we are unable to solve the problem to your satisfaction we will provide you with a full refund of your cookie purchase.

Customer Reviews

Based on 451 reviews
86%
(390)
7%
(32)
5%
(23)
1%
(4)
0%
(2)
92.6
83.2
H
Heidi
Delicious!

Most delicious, moist, softest, tastiest cookies I’ve ever tried! So glad I ordered the Best Sellers Mix as I was able to try such a variety! They were all amazing and I will order again and again!

M
Marilyn Hurst
Variety of Cookies

I am disappointed in the taste of the cookies. The lemon are delicious but Publix and Harris Teeter make a better chocolate chip. They don't live up to the hype or cost. The other flavors are ho hum. Sorry, but I am just being honest and thought cookies endorsed by OPRAH would be better.

T
Tina Sauerheber
Best Seller Mix Review

I recently had your cookies at work from a vendor as a 'thank you'! They were absolutely amazing and some of the best cookies I have ever tasted. Because of this I placed an order for my twin daughters upcoming birthday for the same mix of cookies. Upon arrival I noticed a lot of the cookies were dry and crumbly and the flavors and amount of ingredients (chips, zest) was in no way comparable to the ones I had tried at work. The lemon cookies had no noticeable glaze and you could not taste the lemon zest that was so prominent in the first one I tried. I am not sure why there was a difference but there was a huge difference in every flavor. I am not sure if my small batch of cookies just was not as freshly prepared compared to a large marketing order from a larger company or why they were different....but the were. Unfortunately, based on this experience I will not consider ordering again in the future.

Thank you!

D
Danielle Abel
Great service

I ordered these as a gift and they came on time, he loved them !

J
JB

Yummy! bought this and the Adventurous dozen for my spouse's birthday instead of cake. I was a hero. They were all amazing and tasty: we didn't expect to like the Salted Carmel creme as much as we did, and the Cookie Monster was lovely. We will buy these again! Totally worth the calories!

123

Customer Reviews

Based on 451 reviews
86%
(390)
7%
(32)
5%
(23)
1%
(4)
0%
(2)
92.6
83.2
H
Heidi
Delicious!

Most delicious, moist, softest, tastiest cookies I’ve ever tried! So glad I ordered the Best Sellers Mix as I was able to try such a variety! They were all amazing and I will order again and again!

M
Marilyn Hurst
Variety of Cookies

I am disappointed in the taste of the cookies. The lemon are delicious but Publix and Harris Teeter make a better chocolate chip. They don't live up to the hype or cost. The other flavors are ho hum. Sorry, but I am just being honest and thought cookies endorsed by OPRAH would be better.

T
Tina Sauerheber
Best Seller Mix Review

I recently had your cookies at work from a vendor as a 'thank you'! They were absolutely amazing and some of the best cookies I have ever tasted. Because of this I placed an order for my twin daughters upcoming birthday for the same mix of cookies. Upon arrival I noticed a lot of the cookies were dry and crumbly and the flavors and amount of ingredients (chips, zest) was in no way comparable to the ones I had tried at work. The lemon cookies had no noticeable glaze and you could not taste the lemon zest that was so prominent in the first one I tried. I am not sure why there was a difference but there was a huge difference in every flavor. I am not sure if my small batch of cookies just was not as freshly prepared compared to a large marketing order from a larger company or why they were different....but the were. Unfortunately, based on this experience I will not consider ordering again in the future.

Thank you!

D
Danielle Abel
Great service

I ordered these as a gift and they came on time, he loved them !

J
JB

Yummy! bought this and the Adventurous dozen for my spouse's birthday instead of cake. I was a hero. They were all amazing and tasty: we didn't expect to like the Salted Carmel creme as much as we did, and the Cookie Monster was lovely. We will buy these again! Totally worth the calories!

123