Old Cookie Flavors

158 products

Best Seller box. A half dozen cookies in a white cookie box.

Just the way you want it

Create your own personalized cookie mix with any of our signature or monthly flavors.

Starting from $39.95

Build your Own Cookie Box

Sold out

Old Flavor

Krispy M&Ms

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Cotton Candy

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Oatmeal Blueberry

From $18.95

March

Sold out

Old Flavor

Mix

March Mix2 reviews

Top o' the mornin' to ya! Celebrate March with our whimsical cookie collection, perfect for St. Patrick's Day festivities!

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Ultimate S'mores

From $18.95

April

Sold out

Old Flavor

Mix

April Mix

Embrace the flavors of spring with our April Cookie Mix, featuring a delightful array of treats including Walnut Wipeout, Crumbly Latte, Choco-Caramel, Animal Cracker, Unicorn Snack, and Blueberry Bash cookies for a seasonal indulgence in every bite.

From $19.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Vanilla Sugar1 review

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Trick or Treat Cookies with M&Ms flat lay

Bloody Trick or Treat

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Coffee Milkshake1 review

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Pina Colada

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Toffee Cookie with Heath Bar Chunks - Flatlay

Toffee Love

From $18.95

Best Seller's Mix

Sold out

Old Flavor

Mix

Mother's Day Box - Best Seller's Mix

Celebrate the incredible women in your life with a box of irresistible cookies.

From $34.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Strawberry Pop Tart2 reviews

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Pecan Cinnamon Roll1 review

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Almond Shortbread1 review

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Independence Day Mix1 review

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Funfetti Cheesecake

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Shamrock4 reviews

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Caramel Blondie Brownie

From $18.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Lemonade Raspberry Cookies - Pink Sparkles Top View

Raspberry Lemonade

From $18.95

July

Sold out

Old Flavor

July Mix

Celebrate Independence Day and the flavors of summer with our July Cookie Mix, featuring a delightful assortment including Coconut Tiki Bar, Orange Creamsicle, Beach Bonfire S'mores, Berry Basil Breeze, Tropical Trail Mix, and Sunset Love cookies for a festive and delicious holiday treat.

From $15.95

$19.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Nutty Mix

$29.95

Sold out

Old Flavor

Blonde Brownie cookies - Stacked Cookies

Gold Coin2 reviews

From $18.95

Every day is a reason to celebrate

Unique, Handcrafted Cookies

We’re always switching up our menu to provide unique cookie flavors to make your tastebuds tingle.

High Quality Ingredients

Our cookie shop's menu is inspired by ingredients from around the world and contain no added preservatives.

Made to Order

All of our cookies are baked and cookie shipping happens within 24 hours to maintain freshness and quality.

Gifts for Any Occasion or Budget

From everyday occasions to holidays, The Cravory Cookies store offers cookie gifts for any budget.

Something for Everyone

With our signature gourmet cookies and 6 new monthly flavors, there’s a treat for absolutely anyone.