Pumpkin + Marshmallows + Butterfinger + Chocolate + Butterscotch + Spices

October Flavors

The Spookiest Treats

October calls for mischief, and this month's mix totally delivers.

Our Jack O’ Lantern cookies starts with rich butterscotch dough studded with crunchy Butterfinger pieces, melty semisweet chocolate chips, and festive fall sprinkles. While Ghoulish Pumpkin cookies folds roasted pumpkin, gooey mini marshmallows, warm autumn spices, and creamy white chocolate chips into a tender pumpkin dough.

Perfect for porch-sharing, party plates, or late-night trick-or-treating.

Pumpkin + Marshmallows + Butterfinger + Chocolate + Butterscotch + Spices

Filters

Sort by:

6 products

New! October
October Mix CookiesOctober Mix Cookies
An assortment of our two new spooky treats: Jack O'Lantern and Ghoulish Pumpkin
Sale priceFrom $19.95
New! October
Ghoulish Pumpkin CookiesGhoulish Pumpkin Cookies
Soft pumpkin cookie with roasted pumpkin, gooey mini marshmallows, warm spices, and white chocolate chips.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
New! October
Jack O’ Lantern CookiesJack O’ Lantern Cookies
Butterscotch dough loaded with Butterfinger crunch and semisweet chips, finished with festive fall sprinkles. Spooky sweet and totally snackable.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
New! September
Mix
September Mix CookiesSeptember Mix Cookies
Experience the flavors of fall in every bite with our Hazelnut Mocha Crunch and Caramel Apple Cake cookies
Sale priceFrom $19.95
New! September
Caramel Apple Cake CookiesCaramel Apple Cake Cookies
Cinnamon-spiced dough swirled with apple cider jam, caramel bits, and topped with caramel glaze
Sale priceFrom $19.95
New! September
Hazelnut Mocha Crunch CookiesHazelnut Mocha Crunch Cookies
Hazelnut cookie dough blended with espresso reduction and semisweet chocolate chips
Sale priceFrom $19.95