The Best Substitutes for Chocolate Chips in Cookies

The Best Substitutes for Chocolate Chips in Cookies

Classic chocolate chip cookies are one of the all-time favorite treats that are difficult to replace with something equally as satisfying. While chocolate chips are a standard ingredient in cookies, sometimes you may want to switch things up.

Maybe you're looking for a healthier option, or want to add a different flavor or texture to your cookies. Whatever your reason may be, using chocolate chip substitutes can open up a whole new world of baking possibilities.

Whether you're vegan, have a nut allergy, or simply want to try something new, there are many alternatives to chocolate chips that can add a unique twist to your favorite cookie recipe. In this article, we'll share some of our favorite chocolate chip substitutes and tips for using them in your baking adventures.

Chocolate Bar

Chocolate Crunch Bar - Chocolate Bar

Thick, square chocolate bars are one of the greatest alternatives to chocolate chips if you're trying to elevate your chocolate chip cookie game. When navigating the world of chocolate bars, there are many options to pick from, including white chocolate and dark chocolate. Everything from huge chocolate cookies to fluffy pancakes can benefit from this significant improvement, whether you opt for a well-known brand like Hershey's or a small-batch, artisan chocolate bar. Simply chop 

For a chocolate core that adds some depth to the flavor and texture of the cookie, drop a square of chocolate directly on top of the cookie dough as an alternative to baking the chocolate bar bits into the cookie.

Butterscotch Chips

Chocolate Chip and Butterscotch Cookies

There are not many more luscious cookie additions than classic chocolate chips, but if we were to pick one alternative, it would be butterscotch chips. Even though they resemble caramel or toffee in appearance and even flavor, butterscotch chips undoubtedly win the game when it comes to taste.

The fundamental distinction between caramel and butterscotch is that the former uses granulated sugar while the latter uses brown sugar. This significant difference make butterscotch chips richer and more sophisticated in flavor, which can elevate the taste of your homemade cookies.


Chocolate Chip & Almond Cookies

If you're looking for a protein-rich and crunchy substitute for chocolate chips, nuts are a great option. Peanuts, chopped walnuts, almonds, and pecans are all popular choices that work well in cookies. Which ones will be the best choice? This will depend on your flavor preferences. While peanuts have a distinct and pretty strong taste, cashews and almonds are milder so opt for the ones that will suit your taste buds better. 

Top tip: You can also try using nut butter chips, which are made from ground nuts and have a similar texture to chocolate chips.

One thing to keep in mind is that some people have nut allergies, so be sure to check with your guests before serving nut-based cookies.

Cacao Nibs

It’s not just nuts that can provide a delightful crunch to your cookies - raw cacao nibs also fulfill that role pretty well and they are often used as a substitute for classic chocolate chips.

Cacao nibs, sometimes known as "nature's chocolate chips," can be used in place of chocolate chips to add a crisp texture and vibrant flavor. While both cocoa nibs and chocolate chips are sourced from the cocoa bean, cocoa nibs are a more unprocessed form with earthier overtones and a coarser texture. In spite of this, cacao nibs provide sharpness to cookies, elevating texture if you enjoy a little grit.

However, it's crucial to remember that cacao nibs are simply pure cocoa beans that haven't been ground with any additional sugars or chemicals when it comes to flavor. Consequently, their taste is less sweet and more bitter. Cacao nibs also have a roasted coffee flavor, which will give your cookies more complexity and depth.


Chocolate Chip and Raisin Cookies

One of the finest aspects of using raisins in place of chocolate chips is the texture. Although some people might find a raisin's wrinkled appearance to be a little unappealing, raisins are softer than chocolate chips, which make them an excellent alternative to use in your cookies. With fluffy muffins or freshly baked cookies, this chewy and soft texture goes incredibly well. 

And, if you use trail mix raisins you will be able to get some savory aspect in your cookies as the raisins often have a slightly salty coating. A little salt will bring the taste of your cookies to another level, so don’t hesitate to experiment. 

Carob Chips 

Carob chips are a popular healthy substitute for chocolate chips in cookies, which offer a range of nutritional benefits while still maintaining a strong level of sweetness. Carob does not contain caffeine and is a good source of vitamin A. When it comes to minerals, it contains valuable copper, calcium, manganese, potassium, magnesium, zinc, and selenium. 

Carob chips are the most similar alternative to chocolate chips in terms of size and shape, despite the fact that they come in a variety of forms, including powder and syrup. They are less bitter and sweeter than chocolate, although taste very similar to it. For some chocolate enthusiasts, carob chips taste even better than chocolate chips when mixed into cookie dough, muffin batter, or pancake batter.

Yogurt Chips

Yogurt chips, apart from being light, refreshing, and clean in taste, have more nutritional value than chocolate chips, which makes them a perfect healthy alternative to the classic addition. Yogurt-based chips also give you a chance to up your protein consumption without compromising the flavor of your cookies.

If you're searching for something with a comparable texture to your favorite chocolate chips but with a fresher and lighter flavor, then yogurt chips are undoubtedly your best bet. 

Cocoa Butter

Cocoa butter can also be used to mimic the decadent flavor and rich texture of chocolate chips, despite the fact that it won't create the same structure or texture. Instead of serving as a garnish or topping when used to make cookies, use cocoa butter as the foundation of the dough. In addition to its flavor, cocoa butter's creamy, dense texture will also add to the moistness and richness of your cookies. 

Cocoa Powder

When it comes to melting chocolate, cocoa powder, as opposed to chocolate chips, produces a creamier and more delicious combination. As long as you don't use too much when baking, the flavor of cocoa powder shouldn't be too overbearing. Its real, rich flavor is both potent and satisfying.

If you decide to try cocoa powder as your chocolate chips alternative, make sure you use butter in your cookie recipe as it is a key component that allows the powder to dissolve. By dissolving the powder in the butter, the dough is free of any powdery or grainy texture. Such a creamy mixture of butter and cocoa powder produces a tasty and velvety glaze. If your preferred recipe calls for sweetness, you can increase it even further by adding a little sugar to your mixture.

Tips for Using Chocolate Chip Substitutes

When using chocolate chip substitutes in your cookies, there are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Adjust your recipe accordingly. Different substitutes can affect the texture and baking time of your cookies, so be sure to adjust your recipe accordingly.
  • Chop your substitutes into small pieces. Whether you're using nuts or fruit, be sure to chop them into small pieces before adding them to your cookie dough.
  • Experiment with different combinations. Don't be afraid to mix and match different substitutes to find your perfect cookie recipe.
  • Consider your guests' dietary restrictions. If you're serving your cookies to guests, be sure to consider any dietary restrictions, such as nut allergies or vegan preferences.

The Bottom Line

Whether you're looking for a healthier option, want to try something new, or have dietary restrictions, there are many alternatives to chocolate chips that can add a unique twist to your cookies. From nut-based and fruit-based substitutes to carob chips and cocoa butter, the possibilities are endless. Experiment with different combinations and have fun exploring the world of chocolate chip substitutes.

Reading next

Chocolate chip marshmallow cookies
A Guide to Pairing Chocolate Chip Cookies with Milk - Cookies in Jar with Milk
Re-Imagining the Traditional Cookie