We Made Too Much!
Uh oh, looks like we bit off more than we can chew. Lucky for you, that means discounted cookies. Discover our current flavors on sale!
Filters
8 products
Mix
Be delighted, be surprised, be happy you have 48 cookies to eat and share, because this cookie box is the ultimate cookie lovers dream come true.
DecemberOn sale
Indulge in the Peppermint Bark Cookie, a festive treat that blends rich milk chocolate dough with semisweet and white chocolate chips, topped with crushed peppermint candy for the perfect balance of minty freshness and chocolatey sweetness.
DecemberOn sale
Our Pumpkin Pecan Pie Cookie combines soft pumpkin dough, candied pecans, roasted pumpkin, and gooey marshmallows for a deliciously cozy fall treat.
DecemberOn sale
Taste the holidays with our Eggnog Cookie which combines rich, eggnog-infused dough with warm spices and a nutmeg sugar topping, capturing the cozy flavors of the classic holiday drink.
DecemberOn sale
The Lump of Coal Cookie is a decadent treat for the "naughty" and "nice" alike, featuring rich dark chocolate dough filled with gooey caramel bits and semisweet chocolate chips for a perfect balance of bold and sweet flavors.
DecemberOn sale
Enjoy our festive Christmas Tree Cookie which blends buttery vanilla dough with vibrant Fruity Pebbles and creamy vanilla chips, creating a treat perfect for celebrating the season.
DecemberOn sale
Delight in our Gingerbread Cookie that combines spiced gingerbread dough, dark chocolate callets, and a turbinado sugar topping for a warm, festive treat.
DecemberOn sale
Mix
Celebrate the holiday season with our December Cookie Mix featuring a festive assortment of Peppermint Bark, Pumpkin Pecan Pie, Eggnog, Lump of Coal, Christmas Tree, and Gingerbread cookies, each crafted to capture the joy and warmth of the holiday season.