We Made Too Much!
Uh oh, looks like we bit off more than we can chew. Lucky for you, that means discounted cookies. Discover our current flavors on sale!
Filters
9 products
Mix
Be delighted, be surprised, be happy you have 48 cookies to eat and share, because this cookie box is the ultimate cookie lovers dream come true.
AugustOn sale
Indulge in the sweetest days of summer with our irresistible Peachy Keen cookie, a delectable treat that captures the essence of a sun-kissed orchard, bursting with dried peaches, velvety peach jam, creamy Nilla Wafers, and a sprinkle of white chocolate chips.
SeptemberOn sale
Savor the rich, buttery sweetness of our Chewy Butterscotch Cookie, featuring butterscotch dough, dark chocolate callets, butterscotch chips, and a sprinkle of Maldon sea salt for a perfectly balanced treat.
SeptemberOn sale
Delight in our Nutella Wonder Cookie, featuring Nutella-infused dough, roasted hazelnuts, swirls of Nutella, and semisweet chocolate chips for a rich and indulgent treat.
SeptemberOn sale
Relish our Brookie Cookie, a decadent blend of brownie batter dough, semisweet chocolate chips, milk chocolate chunks, chewy brownie bites, and a dark chocolate drizzle for an ultimate chocolate indulgence.
SeptemberOn sale
Savor the wholesome goodness of our Cherry Granola Cookie, featuring granola dough, cherry jam, dried cherries, oats, and granola for a perfect blend of sweet and chewy flavors.
SeptemberOn sale
Mix
Embrace back-to-school season with our September Cookie Mix, featuring a variety of flavors including Spiced Apple Chai, Strawberry Cream Pie, Cherry Granola, Nutella Wonder, Chewy Butterscotch, and Brookie Cookie for a delightful and diverse treat.
SeptemberOn sale
Enjoy the warm, comforting flavors of our Spiced Apple Chai Cookie, featuring chai-infused dough, tender spiced apples, and crunchy Nilla wafers for a delightful treat.
SeptemberOn sale
Savor the nostalgic flavors of our Strawberry Cream Pie Cookie, with buttery shortbread dough, strawberry jam, a strawberry white chocolate truffle, and a vanilla drizzle for a delightfully indulgent treat.