We Made Too Much!
Assorted cookies on wooden tray

We Made Too Much!

Uh oh, looks like we bit off more than we can chew. Lucky for you, that means discounted cookies. Discover our current flavors on sale!

We Made Too Much!

Filters

Sort by:

8 products

DecemberOn sale
Peppermint Bark CookiePeppermint Bark Cookies stacked
Our new Peppermint Bark cookies include a milk chocolate dough packed with semisweet chocolate and white chocolate chips. Lastly a generous crumble topping of peppermint candy ties it all together and sends your tastebuds for a joyous ride.
Sale priceFrom $12.95 Regular price$18.95
DecemberOn sale
Lump of Coal CookiesLump of Coal Cookies
Made with a dark chocolate dough, Irish cream, dark chocolate truffle and caramel bits– this treat might be the best gift yet
Sale priceFrom $12.95 Regular price$18.95
JanuaryOn sale
Caramapple Pie CookiesCaramapple Pie Cookies
Rich caramel, luscious apple pie filling, and a delectable caramel glaze come together in every bite of our Caramapple Pie Cookies – a comforting and irresistible treat that captures the essence of a classic caramel apple pie.
Sale priceFrom $12.95 Regular price$18.95
JanuaryOn sale
Java Jewel CookiesJava Jewel Cookies
Robust coffee, velvety semisweet chocolate, and crunchy Heath Bar bits, deliver a delightful balance of sweetness and caffeine-infused bliss, creating a true gem for those who savor finer, flavorful moments in every treat.
Sale priceFrom $12.95 Regular price$18.95
JanuaryOn sale
Chocolate Bliss CookiesChocolate Bliss Cookies
A decadent combination of semisweet chocolate chips, dark chocolate chunks, and a luscious caramel drizzle, promising a rich, velvety journey in every perfect bite.
Sale priceFrom $12.95 Regular price$18.95
JanuaryOn sale
Choco-Nutter CookiesChoco-Nutter Cookies
A symphony of rich Reese's cups, velvety peanut butter chips, and delightful Nutter Butter crunch, crafted to blissful perfection for a mouthwatering treat that satisfies every sweet craving.
Sale priceFrom $12.95 Regular price$18.95
JanuaryOn sale
M&Ms Doodle CookiesM&Ms Doodle Cookies
Experience the irresistible harmony of sweet and spicy in our M&M Doodle Cookie—a blissful blend of soft cinnamon-infused dough, colorful M&Ms, and a rich caramel glaze for a luscious, gooey treat that satisfies every craving.
Sale priceFrom $12.95 Regular price$18.95
Save $29.85
Mix
Ultimate cookie box - 48 cookies
Be delighted, be surprised, be happy you have 48 cookies to eat and share, because this cookie box is the ultimate cookie lovers dream come true.
Sale price$89.95 Regular price$119.80