Old Cookie Flavors

Filters

Sort by:

185 products

Best Seller box. A half dozen cookies in a white cookie box.

Just the way you want it

Create your own personalized cookie mix with any of our signature or monthly flavors.

Starting from $39.95

Build your Own Cookie Box
NovemberSold out
Old Flavor
Chocolate Pop Tart CookiesChocolate Pop Tart Cookies
Chocolate Pop Tart1 review
Made with a milk chocolate dough, chocolate pop tart crumbs, chocolate chips and a generous vanilla drizzle.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
NovemberSold out
Old Flavor
1 Spiced caramel oatmeal cookiestack of 5 spiced caramel oatmeal cookies
Spiced Caramel Oatmeal3 reviews
Enjoy one of our Spiced Caramel Oatmeal cookies with your favorite hot beverage or as a special treat all on its own.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
October Cookies - halloween cookies flat layHalloween cookies in Cravory box
October Mix12 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Trick or Treat Cookies with M&Ms flat lay
Bloody Trick or Treat
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Pumpkin cookies with oreo cumble - flat lay
Pumpkin Graveyard3 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Candy Corn Cookies flat lay
Candy Corn Bark3 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Wicked halloween cookies - green cookie with purple icingGreen cookies with purple drizzle stacked on top of each other
Wicked
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Jack o lantern cooking - orange cookies with brown sprinklesJack o lantern cookies stacked on top of each other
Jack O'Lantern3 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
September Fall Flavors
September Mix3 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
coffee milkshake cookies in flatlaycoffee milkshake cookies stacked
Coffee Milkshake1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Pecan Cinnamon Roll Cookies in flatlay
Pecan Cinnamon Roll1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Oatmeal M&M Cookies overlayOatmeal M&M Cookies stacked
Oatmeal M&Ms1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Magic Cookies - Top ViewMagic Cookies - Side View
Magic2 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Lemonade Raspberry Cookies - Pink Sparkles Top ViewRaspberry Lemonade Cookies - Side View
Raspberry Lemonade
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Banana Split Cookies - Top View with Chocolate DrizzleBanana Split Cookies - Stacked Side View
Banana Split
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Funfetti Cheesecake CookiesFunfetti Cheesecake - Side View
Funfetti Cheesecake
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Ultimate S'mores Cookies - Top ViewUltimate S'mores Cookies - Side View
Ultimate S'mores
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
White Chocolate Macadamia Cookies in flatlay
White Chocolate Macadamia1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
vanilla sugar cookies in box
Vanilla Sugar1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Passionfruit and Guava Cookies
Passion Guava2 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Independence Day Cookies MixIndependence Day Cookies Mix
Independence Day Mix1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
blueberry lemon poppy seed cookies
Blueberry Lemon Poppy Seed2 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
mexican watermelon cookies
Watermelon Tajin2 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95