Old Cookie Flavors

Filters

Sort by:

193 products

Best Seller box. A half dozen cookies in a white cookie box.

Just the way you want it

Create your own personalized cookie mix with any of our signature or monthly flavors.

Starting from $39.95

Build your Own Cookie Box
Sold out
Old Flavor
Ultimate S'mores Cookies - Top ViewUltimate S'mores Cookies - Side View
Ultimate S'mores
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
White Chocolate Macadamia Cookies in flatlay
White Chocolate Macadamia1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
vanilla sugar cookies in box
Vanilla Sugar1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Passionfruit and Guava Cookies
Passion Guava2 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Independence Day Cookies MixIndependence Day Cookies Mix
Independence Day Mix1 review
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
blueberry lemon poppy seed cookies
Blueberry Lemon Poppy Seed2 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
mexican watermelon cookies
Watermelon Tajin2 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
funnel cake cookies flatlay
Chocolate Funnel Cake
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Cotton Candy Cookies
Cotton Candy
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Pina colada cookies with cherry
Pina Colada
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Happy Mother's Day Cookies - Cravory Cookies Packaged Cookies
Mom's Favorite27 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Dulce de Leche Cookies - Cookies with Chocolate Drizzle
Dulce de Leche Custard3 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Pink Squirrel Cookies - Red Sugar Cookies
Pink Squirrel7 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Tiramisu Cookies
Tiramisu2 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Razzle Dazzle Cookies - Cookie with Raspberry Jam
Razzle Dazzle5 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Oreo Churro Cookies - Cookies with Chocolate Crumble
Oreo Churro6 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Mango Con Chile Cookies - Cookies with Mango Chunks
Mango Con Chili4 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
May Cookies - Oreo Churro, Razzle Dazzle, Dulce de Leche, Pink Squirrel CookiesMay Cookies - Oreo Churro, Razzle Dazzle, Dulce de Leche, Pink Squirrel Cookies
May Mix12 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Kids cookie box - cat
Kids Cookie Box - Cat1 review
Sale priceFrom $27.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Alpaca Kids Cookie Box - Best Seller's Mix
Kids Cookie Box - Alpaca5 reviews
Sale priceFrom $27.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Easter Bunny Mix
Easter Bunny Mix (One Dozen Best Seller's Mix + FREE Bunny)
Sale price$29.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Easter Mix CookiesEaster Mix Cookies in box
Easter Mix4 reviews
Sale priceFrom $16.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
April Mix CookiesApril Mix Cookies
April Mix12 reviews
Sale priceFrom $18.95