Birthday Cake Cookies + Cookie Monster Cookies + Lemon Bar Cookies + Red Velvet Cookies + Salted Caramel Cream Cookies + Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookies

Oprah's Best Seller's Mix - 18 Cookie Mix

Sale price$39.95
3.9 (30 reviews)

Tax excluded.

With just the right amount of playfulness, color, and imagination, we guarantee you'll be coming back for more.

Read More
Currently Baking
Made to Order

Our cookies are baked by hand by our team in the last 48 hours.

Individually Wrapped

Each cookie is individually wrapped, for maximum freshness!

High quality ingredients

We use only the best ingredients we could find, with no added preservatives.

Go ahead... you deserve it.

Check out our NEW 18 box Best Seller's cookies (3 of each cookie).

This might be our most popular mix, but you got to try it to know what we're talking about. With just the right amount of playfulness, color, and imagination, we guarantee you'll be coming back for more.

Cookies in this Mix

Birthday Cake Cookies
Birthday Cake Cookies Creamy white vanilla chips mock layers of cake frosting and melt ever so slightly so as not to crash the party. Our Birthday Cake Cookie takes the cake. Or…is just better than the cake.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Cookie Monster Cookies
Cookie Monster Cookies With a signature blue vanilla dough that stands out for all the best reasons and a incredible lineups of mix-ins like caramel bites, oreos, mini marshmallows, and chocolate chips.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Lemon Bar Cookies
Lemon Bar Cookies Fresh lemons are hand zested and squeezed to infuse this cookie with a zesty tartness that’s hard to ignore.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Red Velvet Cookie
Red Velvet Cookies This red cookie will certainly be the first to catch your eye. Do not mistake her density for merely surface-level indulgence.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Salted Caramel Cream cookie
Salted Caramel Cream Cookies Vastly popular, this cookie is made with supremely nutty Cravory Salted Caramel. We couldn’t find the right combination of vanilla, caramel, and salt flavors, so we decided to make our own.
Sale priceFrom $19.95
Ultimate chocolate chip cookie flatlay
Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookies The classic cookie made into the ultimate with three types of chocolate and a sprinkle of sea salt. Our Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie has had an extreme makeover and cleverly challenges all others of its kind.
Sale priceFrom $19.95


Don't take our word for it...

Thanks for the love, y'all.

What Cookie Lovers Have To Say

2,000+ 5-star reviews and growing.

It’s hard to articulate just how delicious this cookie is, the flavors mix perfectly and that’s all I know!

Samantha P.

Verified Buyer

I love to bring Cravory cookies to parties. The mix of amazing flavors means there’s something for everyone. But I always hide at least 2 Rosemary cookies away for myself. I’m obsessed.

Elizabeth S.

Verified Buyer

My husband is a cookie fantantic so for our Anniversary I purchased a big box. He loved them. Not a fan of lemon, he said that he never thought he would have liked a lemon cookie. He loves it. He's very hard to please.

Joanna L.

Verified Buyer

I sent these yummy cookies to my cousin for his 65th birthday which he loved. It is great that the cookies are individually wrapped & easy to freeze!

Ellen L.

Verified Buyer

Cookies are delicious, goes without saying. But definitely worth mentioning is the great customer care. Easy online ordering, fast shipment, notifications throughout. Just a great online buying experience.

Steven W.

Verified Buyer

Wow! These cookies are so good! My family loved all of them! My favorite is the Lemon Bar. I will be ordering them in the near future. Thank you!

Lisa H.

Verified Buyer

Customer Reviews

Based on 30 reviews
Jennifer Meyer
Bland taste

As others mentioned, it was hard to distinguish which cookie was which by taste. They all taste similar, very bland. No bursting lemon flavor. Disappointed.


The best cookies ever! So glad I can order them online and delivered


The cookies are very dry.

Lailane L
Lemon bar cookie

Lemon bar cookie was my favorite. The powdered sugar was an nice extra.


Almost all cookies are real hard. Some are good. I've ordered from here before and it was better. Very disappointed.