Signature Flavor

PB Overload Cookies

Sale price$19.95
Sold out
4.6 (43 reviews)

Tax excluded.

Made with an extra nutty dough that is mixed with Resse’s and Guittard chocolate chips, this cookie is next level decadent and smooth.

Number of Cookies: Half Dozen

Orders over one dozen are condensed into a single box. Want to purchase additional boxes? Email us at info@thecravory.com.

  • 5 stars: 34 (79%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (2%)
  • 3 stars: 6 (14%)
  • 2 stars: 2 (5%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
D
Darron

No notes just love

C
Cyrena Bagenstos
Need to label your cookies

These were sent to me as a gift and they almost killed my cousin with there being no labeling being on the PB overload cookies. The PB overload and regular chocolate chip cookies look too similar as you could not see the peanut butter chunks. Otherwise, cookies were delicious.

D
Donna

Delicious and flavorful. Made a great birthday treat. He was sick on his birthday and made him smile. Will be buying again!

A
Anonymous
Perfect mix

A little sweet and crumbly. What a cookie like this should be.

M
Martha Ochoa
It was ok

I prefer the lemon cookies

P
Pj Magruder

PB Heaven i will be ordering again very soon.

L
LaLa Gerber
My favorite

This is the softest most flavorful PB cookie ever. It’s the one cookie that keeps me coming back to cravory!! I love the others but this one is exceptional!

V
Virginia Martin
PB cookie review

Not as good as I had hoped for. The chocolate chips saved it

l
laura trozak
Outstanding!!!

The PB overload cookies are fantastic! My family loved them! In fact I have just placed an order for more. They were shipped in a timely manner, and all came individually wrapped, which is awesome! Highly recommend!!!

S
Stacie Bailey
Yumminess

My son loved these cookies!!

E
Ernest Somers
They were great

Excellent

I
Ira S Sacks
Great PB cookies

Fresh, beautifully packaged, and generous sized yummy cookies

P
Patricia Page
PB Overload, not so much.

Loved the chocolate chip cookies, but the PB didn’t have enough PB flavor to it they were just okay. Would not order them again.

L
Louis Gehring

Simply amazing

H
Heather Carson
Awesome!

Bought these as a bday gift for my father. They were almost cake like and fresh! So delicious! Shipping was super fast.

F
Frenesi Gurganian
The PB cookies are yummy...

We loved the peanut butter cookies. It satisfies our peanut butter fix! We will be ordering more for sure.

M
Maureen Kelly
The best. Of the best.

Ever since the Cravory came out with these delicious cookies, I’ve been a fan. They far surpass an ordinary peanut butter cookie. Bet you can’t eat just one!

C
Cheryl Henry

PB Overload Cookies

P
Paul Carson
Best cookies ever

Cravory Cookies’ Peanut Butter Overload cookies have to be the best cookies ever made on this planet!

R
Regina Baldwin
PB Overload Cookies

These cookies were good. Chocolate Chip were not as expected they didn't look fully rounded like the picture. They were flat. I was hoping for a more full cookie. But tasted good. Also received the Birthday cake cookies earlier last month those were big and delicious 😋 We Loved them!! Not broken at all either.. Soo far they were the winners!! But we will try others.

S
Sarah Gertsema
Amazing!

These peanut butter cookies are fantastic. Great flavor and and they’re a good sized cookie.

N
Nickii
Pretty good

I ordered the pb and chocolate truffles cookies. The size difference of the two were pretty different. I was expecting more of a peanut butter flavor. It threw me off with the chocolate chips and I think there was pieces of peanuts inside. It came individually wrapped in a cute box.

L
Lawrence Wood
Okay cookies

All the cookies where ok but I will not order again. I can walk into many bakeries and buy cookies as good or even better for less. Thank you for good service.

K
Kevin Egeland
Soooooo yummy!

I love a good peanut butter cookie. These are amazing. So packed with peanut buttery goodness. I will be ordering these again. Sooooo yummy!

J
John Sheehan
pb cookies

I thought they were just peanut buuter, I had no idea there was chocolate, while not bad by any means, it just wasnt what I was expecting, I did not go look at ingredients, it said PB overload... so i assumed it was all PB... Wonderkek puts out a really good PB cookie, your chocolate chip cookie however has been the best so far... better than Bang, wonderkek... fat and wierd doesnt put out a "simple" cookie but I have been buying them too... I also appreciated the price discount... I should order again.

L
Lisa Petherbridge
PB Overload

I only got to eat 3 of the cookies. I had left the box with the cookies in it on my stove. I came back to eat one and ants had attacked the box and got inside. They even got into the individual packages. I had to throw out a majority of the cookies. The ones I did try were very good.

P
Peggy Clayton
Such A Good Cookie

I just thought this cookie was so good. The mix of the peanut butter and the choc chip was just perfect.

D
Deanna Bell

PB Overload Cookies

S
Sima Amin
Great

These are my favorite cookies

D
David Chasteen
WoW 😍

Your going to love this peanut butter cookie,
just like all those Cravory cookies..
The peanut butter is smooth and
just the right amount of creamy delicious peanuts

J
James Manning
nice

but too small

D
DF
PB COOKIES

I bought them as a gift for my Grandson and he said they were "really good".

J
Julissa M.
Awesome cookies!!

Really yummy cookies! And the packaging was great too! They were individually packed, so they were all fresh when eaten. Ordering again this week!