Peanut Butter + Semisweet Chocolate Chips + Reese's Cups + Chips

PB Overload Cookies

Sale price$19.95
4.6 (40 reviews)

Tax excluded.

Made with an extra nutty dough that is mixed with Resse’s and Guittard chocolate chips, this cookie is next level decadent and smooth.

Read More
Currently Baking
Number of Cookies: Half Dozen

Orders over one dozen are condensed into a single box. Want to purchase additional boxes? Email us at

Made to Order

Our cookies are baked by hand by our team in the last 48 hours.

Individually Wrapped

Each cookie is individually wrapped, for maximum freshness!

High quality ingredients

We use only the best ingredients we could find, with no added preservatives.

Go ahead... you deserve it.


We'll always have a place in our heart for a creamy, peanut butter cookie.

Our Peanut Butter Cookie takes on a whole new meaning. Made with an extra nutty dough that is mixed with Resse’s and Guittard chocolate chips, this cookie is next level decadent and smooth. We might have to say this is the best peanut butter cookie out there. We swear we can't promise you won't eat them all in one sitting.


Key Ingredients




No added preservatives.


Don't take our word for it...

Thanks for the love, y'all.

What Cookie Lovers Have To Say

2,000+ 5-star reviews and growing.

Huge box of cookies in fun yet classic flavors. Needless to say the birthday boy loved them. Quick shipping. Great communication on the order status.

Jamie S.

Verified Buyer

This is absolutely my favorite Cookie Monster cookie. I’ve tried a handful of this cookie from different cookie shops, and this is my favorite, soft, full of flavor.

Silena T.

Verified Buyer

Loved all the flavors! I will definitely be ordering again!!

Monica M.

Verified Buyer

These are great! Chewy and delicious! I ordered them to be shipped to New York so I wasn't sure what the freshness would be, have no worries they stayed super fresh for over a week(which is how long we took to eat them). I cannot wait to purchase again, and I have already told my friends about them!

Ashley W.

Verified Buyer

These cookies are awesome as usual. They are always moist and delicious. The flavors are always amazing.

Karen C.

Verified Buyer

They were so good! Love that they’re individually wrapped!

Lisa F.

Verified Buyer

Customer Reviews

Based on 40 reviews
Perfect mix

A little sweet and crumbly. What a cookie like this should be.

Martha Ochoa
It was ok

I prefer the lemon cookies

Pj Magruder

PB Heaven i will be ordering again very soon.

Just Lala
My favorite

This is the softest most flavorful PB cookie ever. It’s the one cookie that keeps me coming back to cravory!! I love the others but this one is exceptional!

Virginia Martin
PB cookie review

Not as good as I had hoped for. The chocolate chips saved it