Old Cookie Flavors

Filters

Sort by:

164 products

Sold out
Old Flavor
Toffee Cookie with Heath Bar Chunks - Flatlay
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Honey Cookie with Chocolate Drizzle - Flatlay
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Chocolate Strawberry Choco-Berry Cookies - Valentine's Sprinkles Flatlay
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Cheese and Wine Cookies Flatlay
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Strawberry Pop Tart Cookies FlatlayStrawberry Pop Tart Cookies Stacked
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Caramel Blondie Brownie Cookies FlatlayCaramel Blondie Brownie Cookies Stacked
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Coffee Cake Cookies FlatlayChocolate Coffee Cake Cookies Stacked
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Almond Shortbread CookiesAlmond Shortbread Stacked
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Oatmeal Blueberry Cookies FlatlayOatmeal Blueberry in Cravory Box
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
rice krispie chocolate cookies flatlayCrunchy Chocolate Cookies Stacked
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Naughty Christmas Mix in Cravory BoxNaughty Mix Christmas Cravory Cookies Box
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
December Mix Cookies in boxDecember Mix Cookies stacked
Rock around the Christmas tree with this cravable cookie mix that will keep you dancing all night long.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Christmas Tree CookieChristmas Tree Cookies stacked
Light things up with our take on a classic. Made with a vanilla-infused dough, vanilla chips and Fruity Pebbles, our Christmas Tree cookie is a sure favorite for holiday parties, Christmas mornings or as a holiday gift for a loved one.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
DecemberSold out
Old Flavor
Lump of Coal CookiesLump of Coal Cookies
Made with a dark chocolate dough, Irish cream, dark chocolate truffle and caramel bits– this treat might be the best gift yet
Sale priceFrom $18.95
DecemberSold out
Old Flavor
Gingerbread CookiesGingerbread Cookies stacked
This sugary and spicy treat tops any gingerbread cookie with ginger puree, dark chocolate chunks and a Turbinado sugar topping. Makes the perfect addition to your dessert night or as a holiday gift for a loved one.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Eggnog CookieEggnog Cookies stacked
What's Christmas without the sweetness of eggnog and a little bit of spice?
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Pumpkin Pecan Pie CookiePumpkin Pecan Pie Cookies stacked
This special winter treat is packed full of flavor with a pumpkin-infused dough and a hint of candied pecans and mini marshmallows. The perfect cookie for dunking solo or as a holiday gift for a loved one.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
DecemberSold out
Old Flavor
Peppermint Bark CookiePeppermint Bark Cookies stacked
Our new Peppermint Bark cookies include a milk chocolate dough packed with semisweet chocolate and white chocolate chips. Lastly a generous crumble topping of peppermint candy ties it all together and sends your tastebuds for a joyous ride.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
Sold out
Old Flavor
Box of November mix cookiesStack of November mix cookies
With quitessential autumn spices and lots and lots of chocolate, this the perfect mix for staying cozy all November long.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
NovemberSold out
Old Flavor
Orange Cranberry CookiesOrange Cranberry Cookies
White chocolate chips, tartness from our orange-infused dough, dried cranberries, and an orange reduction. Now that's quintessential autumn flavor.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
NovemberSold out
Old Flavor
Cinnamon Roll CookiesCinnamon Roll Cookies
Our Cinnamon Roll cookies are made with cinnamon dough, our signature white chocolate cinnamon truffle and a savory cream cheese glaze. They'll have you feeling all warm and happy inside!
Sale priceFrom $18.95
NovemberSold out
Old Flavor
Mint Hot Cocoa CookiesMint Hot Cocoa Cookies
Made with a milk chocolate dough and andes mint, these mint hot chocolate cookies will be your new favorites very quickly.
Sale priceFrom $18.95
NovemberSold out
Old Flavor
Pumpkin Dark Chocolate CookiesPumpkin Dark Chocolate Cookies
Pumpkin pie infused-dough packed into a cookie with dark chocolate chunks and a decadent dark chocolate drizzle. We might just call it the perfect fall dessert.
Sale priceFrom $18.95